Last December, Menlo Park ended the month with six single-family homes in inventory. Sixteen homes closed in December 2025, at an average of 108% of list price and a median of $1,706 per square foot. That premium was a point higher than October 2025's and four points above November 2025's. With so few homes left, buyers paid more over asking in December than in either of the two months before it.
This year starts in a different place. In October 2026, Menlo Park had more homes for sale than a year earlier, fewer closings, and a smaller premium over list price, according to the San Mateo County Association of Realtors' October 2026 report, published November 12. For a buyer comparing Peninsula towns this winter, the question is how much of that extra room is still there when the holiday thinning begins.
Four months of Menlo Park single-family sales
These figures come from SAMCAR's monthly single-family tables, which are built on MLSListings data. Each column covers one calendar month.
| Oct 2025 | Nov 2025 | Dec 2025 | Oct 2026 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New listings | 29 | 11 | 9 | 30 |
| Inventory | 30 | 17 | 6 | 35 |
| Homes sold | 32 | 26 | 16 | 25 |
| Average days on market | 13 | 26 | 28 | 23 |
| Median sale price | $2,877,500 | $3,875,000 | $3,550,000 | $3,250,000 |
| Median price per sq. ft. | $1,604 | $1,642 | $1,706 | $1,633 |
| Percent of list received | 107% | 104% | 108% | 104% |
| Months of inventory | 1.0 | 0.6 | 0.2 | 1.4 |
Last year's numbers show supply falling away. New listings dropped from 29 in October 2025 to 11 in November and 9 in December. Inventory dropped from 30 to 17 to 6. Buyers also slowed down, and closings fell from 32 to 26 to 16, but sellers left faster than buyers did. That gap is why months of inventory fell to 0.2 in December 2025, and why the homes that sold that month brought the highest price per square foot of the four months in the table.
The time on market tells the same story. Average days on market doubled from 13 in October 2025 to 26 in November, which looks like a cooling market. December then combined 28 days on market with a 108% sale-to-list ratio. Some homes took longer to sell over the holidays, and the ones that sold still went for more than their asking price.
The county followed the same pattern two years in a row
Menlo Park is a small sample, so one December can mislead. San Mateo County as a whole showed the same shape in both of the last two winters.
According to the MLSListings November 2025 county summary, new single-family listings in San Mateo County fell 54% from October to November 2025, and closed sales fell 23%. The sale-to-list ratio stayed at 105%. In December 2025, listings fell another 45%, county inventory dropped to 191 homes, and buyers still paid 104% of list.
The 2024 season looked much the same. County inventory went from 448 in October 2024 to 328 in November and 166 in December, and sale-to-list held at 105%, 105% and 104% over those three months. Each winter, the number of homes for sale dropped by more than half while the premium over list barely moved.
In January, supply comes back quickly. Countywide new listings rose 216% in January 2025 compared with December 2024, and rose 199% in January 2024 compared with December 2023. In Menlo Park in January 2025, there were 15 new listings and 14 homes in inventory, and only four sales closed, at 98% of list. Four sales is too few to read as a trend, and the 15 new listings that month compare with 9 in December 2025 and 11 in November 2025.
Why October 2026 changes the starting point
On that pattern, a Menlo Park buyer has the most homes to choose from in October and the fewest by late December. This year the October starting point is higher than last year's.
Compared with October 2025, Menlo Park in October 2026 had five more homes in inventory (35 against 30), seven fewer closings (25 against 32), 10 more average days on market (23 against 13), and a sale-to-list ratio three points lower (104% against 107%). Months of inventory rose from 1.0 to 1.4. Every one of those measures moved toward the buyer.
None of this makes Menlo Park a soft market. Buyers still paid 4% over list in October 2026. But if this winter follows the last two, the extra inventory will shrink through December. A buyer who is ready in the weeks around Thanksgiving is choosing from the largest group of homes they will see before the January listings arrive. A buyer who waits for the holiday lull may find, as buyers did last December, that the lull leaves fewer homes and higher premiums.
Menlo Park's median sale price moved from $2,877,500 in October 2025 to $3,875,000 the next month and $3,250,000 in October 2026. With 16 to 32 sales a month, those swings mostly reflect which homes happened to close. In October 2025, the average sale price was $3,619,993, about $740,000 above the median that month, which means a few large sales pulled the average up. Median price per square foot, which stayed between $1,604 and $1,706 across all four months in the table, is a steadier way to track Menlo Park pricing over a single season.
Where Menlo Park's new for-sale homes stand
In many markets, a builder releasing a new phase can take pressure off resale prices. Menlo Park has several ownership projects in its pipeline, and each one is still in planning review, on pause, or in early site work.
The largest is Parkline, Lane Partners' redevelopment of the SRI campus at 333 Ravenswood Avenue. The City Council approved Parkline in fall 2025. Lane Partners has since submitted a revised phase 2 plan that includes 122 single-family homes, 98 small-lot single-family homes and 108 townhomes, according to the City of Menlo Park's Parkline Phase 2 page. The Planning Commission held a study session on September 14, 2026, and the City Council held one on September 22. The plan still needs environmental review and other approvals. For buyers who want a detached house near downtown Menlo Park, this is the one project that could eventually add new single-family homes, and it is still in review.
In the Bayfront area, the Sobrato Organization's project at 123 Independence Drive includes 116 for-sale townhomes in three-story buildings alongside 316 apartments. In July 2026, the Planning Commission approved changes that let Sobrato build the apartments and townhomes on separate timelines. The Almanac reported that Sobrato senior development manager Caroline Layden told commissioners that "the townhome market varies almost day to day, depending both on local and macroeconomic conditions," and that Sobrato had planned to partner with a townhome developer for that part of the project. The city's project page lists the site as under construction: demolition permits have passed or are nearing final inspection, grading permits have been issued, and utility work is underway.
The smaller projects are earlier in the process. The proposal for 34 for-sale condominiums at 1300 and 1308 Hoover Street, near downtown and El Camino Real, is still under city review after an October 1, 2026 finding on development standards. Habitat for Humanity Greater San Francisco's Laurel Landing, eight townhomes on Pierce Road, is in entitlement. Meta paused Willow Village, its approved mixed-use plan on Willow Road with up to 1,730 multifamily units, as of May 1, 2026, according to the city's Willow Village page.
With every project at those stages, a Menlo Park buyer shopping this winter is choosing among existing homes listed by their owners, and the holiday drop in those listings is the supply that matters.
What this means for an offer made in December or January
For a buyer, the October 2026 numbers point to two good windows this winter.
The first is now through the first part of December, before the drop that took Menlo Park inventory from 17 homes in November 2025 to 6 in December. Homes that have been listed for a few weeks are the ones where a 104% market, rather than last fall's 107%, gives a buyer room to talk about price and terms. Last year, average days on market had already doubled by November, so homes that have been listed for a while are a normal part of this season.
The second window is January, when new listings return. It also brings back the buyers who waited through the holidays. In January 2024 and January 2025, countywide new listings roughly tripled from December, and the competition that followed was typical of the start of spring.
December itself is the hardest month. In Menlo Park last year, it had the fewest homes for sale and the highest premium over list in the table above. A buyer who finds the right house in December should plan for a competitive sale, not a holiday bargain.
If you are comparing Menlo Park with other Peninsula towns this winter, my buyer resources and the Menlo Park neighborhood page are good places to start.
If you are weighing a Menlo Park offer before the holidays or waiting for the January listings, I'm glad to talk through the timing with you against these numbers. Reach out to Carmen Miranda, and Let's Connect.